Hacker News

Favorites Setup
Comment by fwlr | original | Grieving the loss of details
[−]fwlr · 2026-10-10 Sat 20:03 UTC · link
This metaphor does fall apart somewhat when you consider that farm tractors are not made from farmhand muscle fibers, whereas LLMs are in fact made out the stuff they’re rapidly replacing.
[−]abalashov · 2026-10-11 Sun 05:17 UTC · link
No, but I think you could tell a sufficiently compelling allegorical / metaphorical story about how farm tractors, in destroying the livelihood of farmhands, might as well have pried their muscle fibres out of their live bodies.
[−]fwlr · 2026-10-11 Sun 07:52 UTC · link
I meant more that you can build farm tractors whether or not you have farmhands; you cannot train LLMs without human text.
[−]abalashov · 2026-10-11 Sun 07:54 UTC · link
For sure. No, there's a tragically awful irony in the fact that the clankers run entirely on the (unpaid for) intellectual output and cognitive labour of humanity, white-collar professionals, academics, specialists and creatives, yet the idea is that these people are supposed to be obsoleted by the clankers.